“Things can get awkward when a tenant makes a request that's outside the terms of their tenancy agreement, and knowing when to be firm and when to be flexible makes it easier to handle those tricky tenant requests calmly and constructively.”
Things are running perfectly smoothly at your rental property when your tenant suddenly makes a request that catches you off guard and leaves you wondering how to respond.
Your tenant might want to personalise your property, or their circumstances may have changed, and it's not always easy to know what's reasonable and what's taking advantage.
You also need to protect your property, income, and peace of mind, and much of it comes down to how established your relationship is with your tenant and how much you trust them.
Knowing your rights and the potential risks is essential to make an informed decision, and our guide to tricky tenant requests is full of expert tips on how you can handle:
- Redecorating proposals
- Hanging things on walls
- Getting one or more pets
- Asking to pause or reduce the rent
- Subletting or getting a lodger
Remember that you don't need to give a firm answer immediately; it's perfectly acceptable to mull things over. Our aim is to help you find a response you're comfortable with, even if it means saying no.

Redecorating proposals
It’s not unusual for a tenant who wants to stay long-term to ask if they can personalise the decor. You don’t have to say yes, but there can be benefits all round, subject to a few considerations:
- If your tenant is willing to invest their own time and money in warm neutral tones, they may well increase your property’s future appeal and value.
- Insist on pre-approval for any colour palettes or materials, ruling out bright or unconventional shades that are hard to cover up.
- We’d suggest a hard ‘no’ on wallpaper, unless your tenant can show they’re using a rental-friendly peel-and-stick removable product.
- Agree in writing whether the original decor must be reinstated before your tenant moves out, and that they’ll be liable for the cost of professional painters to rectify any substandard work.
- If your tenant simply wants to freshen up your existing decor, you could do a deal where you buy the paint, and they supply the labour—saving you hundreds or thousands on a new paint job.
The main thing to keep in mind is that, if your tenant gives notice and you want to start finding a replacement, your marketing could suffer if any rooms are painted in an outlandish colour.
Hanging things on walls
Most of us have things hanging on walls, from pictures and mirrors to coat hooks and shelves. These are a normal part of home life, but they come with additional concerns for landlords.
- While a homeowner isn't automatically better at DIY than a tenant, rented homes change hands more often, increasing the potential for drilling, filling, and damage.
- Suggest freestanding shelving units, coat stands, wardrobe mirrors, over-the-door hooks, and using small picture pins with lightweight frames to minimise the need to drill large holes.
- Keep an eye out during your regular mid-tenancy inspections so you can spot unauthorised fixings and stop them before more appear and turn into disputes.
Alternatively, if your property warrants it, you could install a TV wall mount, coat hooks, and heavy-duty picture fittings so your tenants never need to drill and your plasterwork stays intact.
Getting one or more pets
Pet requests are increasingly common, and legislation now puts the onus on landlords to have a good reason to deny the request. This doesn't mean you can't refuse, but you do need a structured approach:
- Ask for a pet profile to get as much information as possible, including the animal's age, breed, size, training history, and spatial needs.
- Compare this with your property’s accommodation. For example, a top-floor flat with no outside space is far less suitable for a large dog than a house with a garden.
- If you are not the freeholder, check whether the head lease or building management rules (which override tenancy law) either prohibit pets completely or require prior permission.
- Don't try to enforce a pet surcharge, extra deposit, or mandatory additional cleaning fee as these are illegal. Rely instead on your photographic inventory evidence from check-in and check-out.
Legalities aside, various surveys have found that tenants with pets cause less damage and stay longer than non-pet owners, giving you plenty of evidence to allay any personal misgivings.

Asking to pause or reduce the rent
Money matters are, perhaps, the most awkward of all subjects. Receiving a request for a temporary rent freeze or a permanent reduction is challenging, but your tenant could also be stressed about asking.
Let's take a look at how to handle either situation.
- For a rent pause or temporary reduction due to financial hardship, ask for documentation to support their request, along with a plan to bring payments back up to date.
- Consult your letting agent or solicitor to ensure any temporary concession is documented correctly as a formal variation.
- If your tenant is asking for a permanent reduction by claiming local rental values have gone down, review market rates with your agent or online to see whether a reduction is justified.
Whatever the case, keep communication open, empathetic and strictly professional, so your tenant understands their obligations remain legally binding until you reach an agreement.
Subletting or getting a lodger
With the rising cost of living, your tenant may want to ease their bills by taking in a lodger if there’s spare room. Or they may want to go travelling while keeping their home and recouping some rent.
Each scenario presents its own considerations, so if you're on the fence about how to respond, think about the following before agreeing to anything:
- Check your mortgage lender’s and insurance provider’s policies. Lodgers are often allowed with proper vetting, while subletting is generally banned.
- In the case of lodgers, your tenant effectively becomes their landlord, but as the actual landlord, you can insist on full referencing and final approval.
- For subletting, the nature of someone's stay matters a lot. If they’re using your property as their temporary home (and not a holiday let), they could be granted an automatic assured tenancy.
- While most short lets may be trouble-free, a revolving door of transient tenants means more wear and tear, along with another communication layer in case of problems or emergencies.
In short, getting a lodger out of necessity can stabilise a tenancy and benefit everyone, while subletting to fund a holiday is purely a tenant’s lifestyle choice that adds to a landlord's risk.
Are you dealing with any tricky tenant requests?
We’re here to handle every property management scenario so you don’t have to, and we help many landlords in the Wilton and Salisbury area maintain calm, profitable tenancies.
If you’d like your investment to stay protected and your boundaries to be clear, call us on 01722 580059 or message us at info@piccoloproperty.co.uk for a friendly chat with our team.





Share this with
Email
Facebook
Messenger
Twitter
Pinterest
LinkedIn
Copy this link